Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy, March 2002, p. 848-853, Vol. 46, No. 3
0066-4804/02/$04.00+0 DOI: 10.1128/AAC.46.3.848-853.2002
Copyright © 2002, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.
Leptospira Laboratory, Institut Pasteur de Nouvelle-Calédonie, 98845 Nouméa Cedex, New Caledonia
Received 27 June 2001/ Returned for modification 4 September 2001/ Accepted 26 November 2001
|
|
|---|
|
|
|---|
For many decades there has been controversy about the efficacy of antibiotics in the treatment of human leptospirosis, because few controlled studies have been conducted. In anicteric leptospirosis, oral doxycycline was reported to significantly reduce the course of the disease and to prevent leptospiruria (14). Intravenous penicillin G, in one study, was found to cause clinical improvement in acute leptospirosis with renal failure (Weil's disease), even if administration was delayed (25). However, a contrary result was obtained in another comprehensive investigation (5).
A few studies have evaluated the in vitro susceptibility of Leptospira spp. to antimicrobial agents (6, 17, 20). These showed a high degree of efficacy of a broad range of antibiotics. Among those clinically usable for human treatment, the lowest MICs were obtained with ampicillin, penicillin, tetracycline, and ciprofloxacin.
Using PCR (3, 15) to follow up patients treated with standard antibiotic regimens (10) it was shown that leptospires persist for up to 1 year in urine (3) and for up to 40 days in blood (15). In a hamster model, leptospires were seen in intercellular locations (24). Leptospires were also able to invade Vero cells in vitro (16).
There remains reason for concern about the ability of usual antibiotic treatments to remove leptospires from locations where they may be protected from the immune response. Here, we report in vivo data on the efficacy of ampicillin, doxycycline, and ofloxacin against Leptospira interrogans serovar icterohaemorrhagiae strain Verdun in a hamster model of leptospirosis. These antibiotics were selected because they are used clinically for human treatment (10) and because of their different pharmacokinetics within the host. After treatment, the density of leptospires was monitored in the main target organs (liver, kidneys, lungs, heart, and spleen) and in blood, by using a quantitative PCR assay.
|
|
|---|
Experimental infections. Syrian hamsters weighing 45 to 55 g were sublethally infected subcutaneously with 108 virulent leptospires (day 0). For each antibiotic tested, the treated group included 18 animals (three hamsters tested per day) in order to perform a 6-day kinetic study. Antimicrobial agents were given using a 4-day regimen (days 3 to 6). Untreated infection controls (18 hamsters) were inoculated under the same conditions. Both treated and untreated hamsters were sacrificed each day from days 1 to 6 after inoculation. Each set of experiments, including control animals, was conducted in duplicate. At necropsy, blood and target organs (liver, kidney, spleen, lung, and heart) were collected for quantitative PCR testing.
Therapeutic trials. Drugs tested were standard injectable formulations of ampicillin (Bristol-Myers Squibb), doxycycline (Pfizer), and ofloxacin (Roussel Diamant), ready to use or diluted in sterile water for injection. Drug dilutions were freshly prepared before use in order to deliver the appropriate dose in a volume of 0.15 to 0.30 ml. Antimicrobial agents were given intramuscularly once daily from day 3 to day 6 in the cranial part of the thigh. Ampicillin and ofloxacin were used at doses of 40 or 100 mg/kg of body weight and 15 or 30 mg/kg, respectively. Doxycycline was used at a single dose of 10 mg/kg.
Quantitative PCR testing. For estimation of leptospiremia, the maximum amount of blood was collected by cardiac puncture from each sacrificed animal. Selected organs were carefully washed, after collection, in sterile phosphate-buffered saline (bioMerieux), to minimize the presence of leptospires due to contamination with blood. Tissue specimens (0.07 to 0.90 g) of liver, kidney, spleen, heart, and lungs were mechanically disrupted in a mortar using 1 ml of sterile phosphate-buffered saline buffer. Suspensions were centrifuged to remove cellular debris (10 min at 1,300 x g), and the supernatants (500 µl) containing leptospires were subjected to DNA extraction. Purification of DNA, amplification, and hybridization in a microplate assay were performed as previously described (23). Briefly, leptospiral DNA was purified using silica particles and guanidium thiocyanate lysis buffer, and 10 µl of eluted DNA in TE buffer (10 mM Tris, pH 7.6; 1 mM EDTA) was used for subsequent amplifications (15). The biotin-labeled amplified product (331-bp fragment of the rrs gene) was hybridized with a complementary capture probe (289 bp) covalently linked onto aminated polystyrene wells (Covalink NH microplates). The hybrid molecules were detected by extravidine conjugated with alkaline phosphatase and a chromogenic substrate.
Samples negative in the quantitative microplate assay were confirmed as negative using a highly sensitive dot filter hybridization test (15).
Statistical analysis. Mean leptospiral densities (each with standard deviation [SD]) were calculated for each organ and each day for each duplicated set of results (three hamsters per result). Efficacies of antibiotics were evaluated using Student's t test, comparing treated and untreated animals. Results were considered significant when P was <0.05.
|
|
|---|
![]() View larger version (44K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. Efficacy of ampicillin (40 and 100 mg/kg) for treating leptospirosis in hamsters (three hamsters per day in duplicate). Ampicillin was administered once daily in a 4-day regimen (long black arrow) from day 3 (short black arrow) to day 6. Results are mean values of leptospiral density + SDs (error bars).
|
Doxycycline treatment. Figure 2 shows changes with time in the densities of virulent leptospires after treatment with doxycycline at 10 mg/kg (striped bars). Two days after the outset of the treatment, leptospires were cleared from blood (Fig. 2A), kidneys (Fig. 2B), lungs (Fig. 2D), heart (Fig. 2E), and spleen (Fig. 2F) (P < 0.05). Clearance from liver (Fig. 2C) did not occur until day 5, after 3 days of treatment.
![]() View larger version (47K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. Efficacies of doxycycline (10 mg/kg [striped bars]) and ofloxacin (15 and 30 mg/kg [open and shaded bars, respectively]) for treating leptospirosis in hamsters (three hamsters per day in duplicate). Antibiotics were administered once daily in a 4-day regimen (long black arrow) from day 3 (short black arrow) to day 6. Results are mean values of leptospiral density + SDs (error bars). Solid bars, untreated controls.
|
For the three therapeutic trials, samples negative by the quantitative microplate assay were confirmed as negative using the filter hybridization test.
|
|
|---|
Since the 1950s, however, there has been controversy about the efficacy of antibiotics for treating human leptospirosis. This is essentially because of differences between the clinical trials (timing of the treatment, differences in doses, and absence of control groups). Studies with homogeneous groups of patients are difficult because of the broad range of clinical forms of the disease. Three controlled randomized studies have been designed to clarify the situation. McClain et al. (14) concluded that oral doxycycline reduced the clinical expression of anicteric systemic leptospirosis and prevented leptospiruria. Conflicting results have been reported for penicillin. Watt et al. (25) reported that penicillin had a similar impact on these two parameters in patients with severe leptospirosis (with icterus and/or renal insufficiency). On the other hand, Edwards et al. (5) concluded that penicillin has little effect on clinical outcome in icteric leptospirosis. In these studies, leptospires in blood and urine were detected by culture, which is known to have poor efficiency (9). For the mild forms of human leptospirosis, there are no clinical trials to support the antibiotic therapies currently prescribed (10), which are based on ampicillin, amoxicillin, or doxycycline.
The efficacy of antibiotics has also been evaluated in two studies using laboratory animals. Alexander and Rule (2), in a study of hamsters infected with serovar bataviae, reported that seven beta-lactams and two cyclins were effective when animals were treated early in the course of the disease. Furthermore, ampicillin and doxycycline prevented the occurrence of leptospiruria in survivors. Another study showed that ciprofloxacin was effective in hamsters infected intraperitoneally with serovar budapest (20). In these two studies, the efficacy of antibiotic therapy was assessed from the survival of challenged animals and by culture of leptospires from target organs.
In our study, we used a sensitive quantitative PCR to monitor leptospiral density in target organs, in order to monitor the course of the disease and the effectiveness of the treatment. In contrast to the previous studies with experimental animals (2, 20), we tried to define experimental conditions as close as possible to those in a natural infection: (i) the infecting serovar was icterohaemorrhagiae, which is involved in the majority of human infections (9), and (ii) the subcutaneous route of infection was selected instead of the intraperitoneal one. The in vivo efficacy of the selected antibiotics in hamsters was evaluated by comparing leptospiral density in target organs between control and treated animals. The choice of antibiotics and their respective doses was based on previous experimental studies in hamsters (2, 20) and on current recommendations for the treatment of the human disease (10). Antibiotics were administered 3 days after challenge with leptospires, this being a compromise between early and delayed treatments investigated in previous studies (2, 20). The timing of the initiation of antibiotic treatment in human leptospirosis has been reported as critical to success in preventing severe disease manifestations (25).
In our model, ampicillin (both 40 and 100 mg/kg) reduced the number of leptospires in all the target organs tested (Fig. 1). A dose of 40 mg/kg was unable to clear the leptospires from any of the organs studied; a dose of 100 mg/kg was more effective, although leptospires remained detectable in kidneys and heart. Indeed, the susceptibility of leptospires to ampicillin in vitro (17) did not predict in vivo efficacy in our model. This seems consistent with a reported study of leptospiruria in hamsters treated orally or subcutaneously with ampicillin (2). Possibly the administration of ampicillin only once daily in our study might be inappropriate for eradication of leptospires from all tissues.
Conversely, doxycycline is effective in vivo early in the course of the disease: clearance of leptospires was observed in all the target organs on the second day of treatment, except in liver, which required an additional day. With a daily administration, both ofloxacin regimens were ineffective in blood and kidneys. Lungs, spleen, liver, and heart were cleared of leptospires with the dose of 30 mg/kg.
The high capacity of some quinolones to diffuse in cerebrospinal fluid and in aqueous humor could lead to their use in neurologic (9) or ophthalmologic (4) forms of leptospirosis; this possibility was not explored in our model. It would thus be of interest to monitor the leptospiral density in target organs with various administration schedules of different quinolones.
It is difficult to demonstrate conclusively that quantitative PCR data indicate the presence of viable leptospires in target organs, and the clinical relevance of that is difficult to state (3, 15). However, leptospires have a very fragile outer membrane which is subject, during the course of the disease, to an antibody immune response linked with the complement system (1, 9). The consequent elimination of dead leptospires by the immune system is extremely efficient (9). Classically, in the acute phase of the human disease, which lasts about 10 days, leptospires can be cultured from blood or cerebrospinal fluid (9). When a specific antibody response is detected, leptospires usually disappear from the blood. During the second clinical phase, which may last up to several weeks, bacteriuria is intermittent (9). However, patients treated for leptospirosis caused by some serovars may have a positive PCR for months when urine is tested (3) or up to 40 days when blood is tested (15), without any evident signs of clinical illness. In contrast, an experimental infection study of serovar hardjo in cows (11) and a clinical study of cattle naturally infected with hardjo (12) both showed correlation between negative PCR, cessation of urinary shedding, and clinical recovery. These data emphasize the complexity of the physiopathology of leptospirosis in both humans and animals and the differences in the pathogenicity of leptospires belonging to various species and serovars (9).
The persistence of leptospires in humans after the initial clinical period, in spite of treatment with beta-lactams (3, 15), suggests that these antibiotics are ineffective in clearing leptospires that are located in protected sites. Invasive phenotypes of virulent leptospires, which have been demonstrated in vitro (16), may be able to invade such sites. Our data validate previous evidence that doxycycline has therapeutic and prophylactic value in leptospirosis (14, 21). Unlike the natural cyclins known for their nephrotoxicity, doxycycline has the potential for use in leptospirosis; its intestinal elimination is modulated according to the level of renal insufficiency (19). Our results suggest a second potential value for doxycycline in the treatment of leptospiral pneumonia, a severe manifestation of the disease which is being detected more frequently (9, 13, 22, 26). Nevertheless, doxycycline cannot be recommended for exclusive use, as it is absolutely contraindicated, for example, in children and in pregnancy. Additional experimental studies are therefore needed to validate alternative therapeutic strategies using other antibiotics.
In our model, eradication of leptospires in all tested tissues was only observed with doxycycline (10 mg/kg). On the other hand, other treatments selectively eradicated leptospires from some organs. Eradication is not, however, always necessary for an antibiotic to be considered efficacious. The timing of the antibody response is critical to the control of acute leptospiral infection in rodents (9). BALB/c mice are able to resist peritoneal inoculation with 1010 serovar pomona leptospires by producing circulating antibodies as early as 2 days after infection (1). It appears that, when leptospiral density is below a critical level, the immune system can overcome the infection. In humans, this hypothesis is supported by the finding that, during acute icterohemorrhagic leptospirosis, a leptospiremia under the threshold of 104/ml predicted recovery of the patients (23).
In conclusion, our study demonstrates the value of modeling antibiotic treatment of leptospirosis in laboratory animals. The combination of an animal model and a sensitive PCR-based method for measuring bacterial density in the target organs allows objective evaluation of the efficacy of treatment. Longer-term studies could be performed to investigate persistent leptospirosis; this would require the use of adapted animal models, such as the horse for ocular disorders (8) or the squirrel monkey for Weil's disease (18). Studies of other antibiotic regimens, including associations of antibiotics, are also required to determine the most-suitable antibiotic therapies for human leptospirosis.
Warm thanks are due to Rod Chappel (National Serology Laboratory, Melbourne, Australia) for editorial contributions and to Guy Baranton (Institut Pasteur, Paris) for scientific support.
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»