Previous Article | Next Article ![]()
Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy, April 2007, p. 1351-1358, Vol. 51, No. 4
0066-4804/07/$08.00+0 doi:10.1128/AAC.01270-06
Copyright © 2007, American Society for Microbiology. All Rights Reserved.

Randal Eckert,2,
Thanh Pharm,2
Maurice D. Simanian,2
Chuhong Hu,1
Daniel K. Yarbrough,1
Fengxia Qi,1
Maxwell H. Anderson,3 and
Wenyuan Shi1,2*
School of Dentistry,1 Department of Microbiology, Immunology, and Molecular Genetics, University of California, Los Angeles, California 90095,2 C3 Jian, Inc., Sequim, Washington 983823
Received 11 October 2006/ Returned for modification 7 December 2006/ Accepted 1 February 2007
|
|
|---|
|
|
|---|
-helical or ß-strand confirmation upon interaction with hydrophobic environments (such as detergents or lipid vesicles) that mimic bacterial membranes, suggesting that these conformational changes are necessary for antimicrobial function (22, 44, 45). Additionally, the formation of a membrane-active
-helix (and other structures) appears to require an amphipathic spatial arrangement of residues, i.e., a gradient of hydrophobicity across the surface of the peptide (22, 24, 37). Previously, the rational design of AMPs has focused mainly on variation of the existing natural sequences or development of novel peptides from large combinatorial libraries (4, 19, 22, 35). These efforts have yielded valuable information on AMP structure-activity relationships and design requirements for constructing both wide-spectrum AMPs and peptides selective for fungi and gram-negative or gram-positive organisms.
In this report, we aimed to develop AMPs against Streptococcus mutans. This often overlooked pathogen of the oral cavity is a major causative agent responsible for dental caries, one of the most prevalent and costly bacterial infections worldwide (2, 27, 31, 43). Additionally, new therapeutics against this organism are sorely needed, as S. mutans is a persistent colonizer of the tooth surface in the presence of dietary sugars and can remain in the oral microflora (known as dental plaque) despite dedicated mechanical removal (tooth brushing) and general antiseptic efforts (21).
As we wished to avoid the synthesis of large combinatorial libraries of random peptides, we chose instead to identify peptides with anti-S. mutans activity by rationally designing several small peptide libraries. Each library was limited to peptides of a defined size and structural framework, while the sequences within each library differed in aromatic/hydrophobic residue content, net positive charge, and predicted amphipathic,
-helix-forming character. Furthermore, we conjoined the active sequences to construct new "fusion" peptides to further enhance activity. Here we report the successful utilization of these approaches to construct AMPs active against S. mutans.
|
|
|---|
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 4. MICs of selected peptides against non-S. mutans oral isolates
|
Analytical and preparative reverse-phase high-performance liquid chromatographies (ACTA purifier; Amersham) was conducted with a Source 15RPC column eluted with H2O and CH3CN with 0.1% trifluoroacetic acid in a linear gradient as described previously (13). All peptides were purified to >90% (data not shown). Peptide mass was confirmed by matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization-mass spectrometry and conducted with samples dissolved in a 1:2 mixture of H2O-CH3CN. Measurements were made in the linear mode, with an
-cyano-4-hydroxycinnamic acid matrix (Voyager system; ABI). The mass observed corresponded in all cases with the calculated value (data not shown).
Estimation of peptide characteristics.
Peptide average hydrophobicity per residue (<H>) was calculated using the scale of Fauchere and Pliska (17), available at http://us.expasy.org/tools/pscale/Hphob.Fauchere.html. This method was selected for calculating the hydrophobicity of AMPs due to its agreement with experimental evidence describing the membrane affinity of individual amino acids in a host-guest system (41). The average
-helix-forming propensity per residue (<Helix>) was estimated utilizing the scale developed by Liu and Deber that defines the helical propensities of individual amino acids in nonpolar membrane environments, such as those encountered by AMPs at the surface of the target cell (26).
MIC assays.
Antibacterial growth inhibition assays were performed using sterile 96-well plates in a final volume of 100 µl TH or Veillonella medium as described previously (32). Briefly, bacterial cells were grown overnight to an optical density at 600 nm of 0.75 to 0.8 (corresponding to 1 x 108 CFU/ml) and then diluted to
1 x 105 CFU/ml in broth and aliquoted onto plates. An appropriate volume of peptide stock solution (5 to 20 mg/ml, in water or methanol, depending on solubility) was then added to the first column of the plate to give 500 µg/ml or 512 µg/ml, followed by serial 1:2 dilutions across the plate to give wells containing peptides ranging from 500 to 1.95 µg/ml or 512 to 2 µg/ml. Methanol alone was also added to control for the effects of the solvent. The plates were then incubated at 37°C under anaerobic conditions for 16 to 20 h without shaking, and the MIC was determined as the concentration of peptide present in the last clear well after visual inspection. Up to 5% (vol/vol) methanol was found not to be antimicrobial (data not shown). MICs were determined in triplicate for all bacteria.
Assessment of antimicrobial kinetics.
The determination of killing kinetics for fusion and parental peptides was conducted essentially as described previously (15). Briefly, medium-diluted overnight UA159 cultures (
0.5 x 106 to 1 x 106 CFU/ml) were challenged with peptide at a concentration of 25 µg/ml, and at the indicated time intervals ("0 min" indicates untreated samples), a 10-µl aliquot was removed and the surviving CFU were rescued by dilution (1:50) into growth medium and then spread on TH agar plates for quantitation. Where initial experiments suggested few survivors (<3,000 CFU/ml), entire 1-ml samples were plated without aliquots. Kinetics were determined by recording the average number of surviving CFU/ml versus incubation time in the presence of peptide (all assays were independently repeated three to five times). For Table 3, time to bactericidal killing (TC) values were defined as the time required for the level of surviving CFU/ml from peptide-treated cultures to fall 3 log10 below the levels of recovered S. mutans CFU/ml from untreated samples.
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 3. Bactericidal kinetics of parent RW and fusion FRW library peptides
|
|
|
|---|
-helix, and RW libraries. Peptides within the binary and
-helix libraries were designed from an amphipathic,
-helical sequence arrangement framework (HCCHHCHHCCn, where H is a hydrophobic residue and C is a charged residue) that was developed from several published AMP amphipathic sequence templates (4, 46) and was validated using helical-wheel projections (36) and the average helical propensity <Helix> (Table 1). Figure 1 shows two representative projections from each library. The lengths of the peptides within the binary and
-helix libraries were limited to 11 and 14 amino acids, respectively, near the estimated number of minimal residues required to form membrane-spanning pores (38). From within this structural framework, the binary library was constructed by reducing, in a stepwise manner, the hydrophobic/aromatic and cationic components within a baseline sequence, FKKFWKWFRRF (B-33), via the substitution of less-hydrophobic/aromatic or positively charged residues (B-33 has been published with alternative nomenclature, S6L3-33 [14]). The resulting gradient of charge and hydrophobicity (<H>) within this library of 32 peptides is shown in Table 1. The
-helix library was designed to be longer than the binary library (14 versus 11 amino acids), and in a manner similar to that of the binary library, the hydrophobicity and charge were varied incrementally throughout the
-helix library (Table 1). |
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 1. Sequences and antimicrobial activities of binary, -helix, and RW library peptides against clinical isolates of S. mutans
|
![]() View larger version (29K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 1. -Helix wheel projections for representative peptides from the binary and -helix libraries. Residues are numbered consecutively from the N terminus to the C terminus, with hydrophobic residues shaded.
|
-helix conformations, as reflected in their low <Helix> values. Activity of binary library peptides. The binary library was evaluated for S. mutans activity against a collection of clinical isolates by an MIC assay (Table 1). Two peptides that showed the lowest MICs (range, 8 to 24 µg/ml), B-33 and B-34, were also the most hydrophobic and cationic in the binary library. Similarly, B-37, -38, -41, -53, -54, -57, and -58, peptides that were active but to a lesser degree than B-33 or B-34, possessed net charges of at least +3 and an <H> of >0.55. In contrast, peptides with hydrophobicity values below 0.55 were not antimicrobial, with two exceptions: B-61 and B-62 (MIC range, 16 to 32 µg/ml). Notably, these two peptides each had only one aromatic residue but a net charge of +6 that may contribute to their sustained activity.
The MIC results are consistent with the notion that net positive charge and some hydrophobic content are critical parameters for designing active peptides (8, 9). Accordingly, the addition of negatively charged residues, especially to the central area of the peptide, appears to abolish AMP activity (for example, B-43), likely due to the interruption of the positive charge necessary for peptide attraction to the bacterial surface. The data indicate two interesting exceptions, B-49 and B-50, which are weakly active despite the lack of strong cationic character. The exceptionally high <H> values (and therefore likely rapid partition into host membranes) for these peptides may explain this discrepancy. B-33, -34, and -38, three of the more active peptides from this library, were selected for further enhancement. Interestingly, as was the case throughout this study, no strain of S. mutans appeared more susceptible or resistant to the AMPs tested (data not shown).
Activity of the
-helix library peptides.
As shown in Table 1, many of the
-helix library peptides had robust activities against S. mutans, as evaluated by MIC: only two peptides with low net positive charges or <H> values (
-4 and
-8, respectively) were inactive. Though many
-helix library peptides showed equally robust killing activities against S. mutans,
-11 alone was selected for further modification.
Activity of RW library peptides. As shown in Table 1, we observed that 2C-3 and 2C-4 were the most active peptides against S. mutans (MIC range, 4 to 8 µg/ml) from the RW (Arg- and Trp-rich) library. These data indicate that a near 1:1 ratio of hydrophobic to charged amino acids (including the amidated C-terminal Phe as a charged residue) is required for robust antimicrobial activity, similar to the reported ratio of 4:3 observed by Blondelle and others examining Trp/Arg-rich AMPs (5, 28). RW library peptides with a lower ratio of hydrophobic to charged amino acids (reflected in lower <H> values) were not as active as 2C-3 or 2C-4. Due to their low MICs, these peptides were selected for further enhancement.
Design of fusion AMPs. Previous studies have shown that synthesizing AMPs as conjoined linear dimers or pentameric bundles, in various arrangements, can increase peptide activity compared to that of the single constituent AMP alone (10, 34). In a similar manner, we hypothesized that the activity of the S. mutans-active sequences shown in Table 1 could be improved by synthesizing two AMPs together, head to tail, as a single fusion linear peptide molecule. It was noted in our previous studies that a linker region between peptide domains has an impact on antimicrobial activity (15). Therefore, in the hopes of generating peptides with greater activity against S. mutans, we synthesized a library of fusion peptides (Table 2) that differed in the arrangement of constituent AMPs and the sequence of linker regions (or with no linker) between each.
|
View this table: [in a new window] |
TABLE 2. Sequence and activity of fusion library peptides
|
-helix set, B-33 and B-38 were synthesized with
-11 at the N or C terminus. A tri-Gly linker, which has been shown previously to be effective in separating functionally independent peptide regions within a linear sequence (15) and may be critical for peptide secondary-structure transition in model membranes (40), was employed to separate the two AMP domains. The RW-to-RW set of fusion peptides contained 2C-3 and 2C-4 as linear homodimers with or without various linker regions in between. In the last group shown in Table 2 (binary-to-RW set), 2C-4 was synthesized with B-33, -34, or -38 at the N or C terminus, again separated by a Gly linker region. These arrangements allowed us to investigate the importance of linker composition (and presence) as well as AMP subunit arrangement (N or C terminus within the fusion peptide) on anti-S. mutans activity.
Antimicrobial activity of fusion AMPs.
MICs revealed that fusion AMPs were largely equally or less active than their parent AMPs against S. mutans (Table 2). Exceptions included FB
-20, which had a reduced MIC range compared to either B-33 or
-11, and FBRW-22, which had a slightly reduced MIC range compared with the parent peptide B-33. Overall, these data indicate that fusing AMPs results, at best, in only modest improvements in MIC. However, MIC assays can obscure dramatic differences in killing speed between comparable peptides (15), suggesting that a more detailed analysis of peptide killing kinetics was necessary to fully evaluate fusion AMPs.
The killing kinetics of fusion AMPs against S. mutans were analyzed by time-kill assays. As shown in Fig. 2A, the fusion peptide FB
-21 had an obvious increase in killing kinetics compared to either B-34 or
-11: more than 2 log10 fewer CFU/ml were recovered from fusion peptide-treated cultures than from parental peptide-treated samples after 30 min. This trend was representative of all the FB
peptides (data not shown).
![]() View larger version (34K): [in a new window] |
FIG. 2. Comparative killing kinetics of binary-to- -helix and binary-to-RW fusion peptides. S. mutans was challenged with 25 µg/ml binary-to- -helix (A) or binary-to-RW (B) fusion peptides or parent AMPs, and the surviving CFU were plated at various time points postaddition. Samples at 0 min were plated prior to peptide treatment. All data points represent the average of results of at least three independent experiments ± standard deviations.
|
As shown in Table 3, we also observed an increase in killing kinetics for some RW-to-RW fusion peptides. In samples treated with the 2C-4 homodimer without a linker region (FRW-8), the surviving number of S. mutans CFU/ml dropped 3 log10 below that of untreated samples (defined as time to bactericidal activity, or TC) by 50 min, while 2C-4 had a TC of 220 min. This trend, to a lesser extent, was also present when samples exposed to the 2C-3 homodimer without a linker (FRW-2) were compared to samples treated with its parent peptide (2C-3). Interestingly, the addition of a linker region of flexible amino acids (either PSGSP, ASASA, or GGG) between 2C-3 domains did not result in an improvement in killing kinetics (TC of >250 min for FRW-3 to -5), while 2C-4 homodimers FRW-9 and -11 had increased bactericidal speed relative to that of the parent 2C-4 AMP despite the presence of ASASA and GGG linker regions, respectively (Table 3). These results suggest that RW-based peptide activity against S. mutans can be enhanced by synthesizing peptides together without a linker region, but when a linker region is utilized, the data indicate that increased kinetics are likely sequence and therefore secondary structure dependent, as 2C-4 could be improved by conjugations with linker regions of flexible amino acids (except PSGSP) and 2C-3 could not.
Peptide activity against other oral bacteria.
A set of peptides with the best anti-S. mutans activity (as measured by MIC) were selected to investigate the activity of these AMPs against several normally commensal oral streptococcal strains and Lactobacillus casei, as well as the oral gram-negative organism V. atypica (Table 4). The MIC results indicate that these sequences were active, but to a lesser degree than seen with S. mutans, against Streptococcus gordonii, L. casei, and Streptococcus sanguinis. All peptides examined were typically only weakly active against Streptococcus mitis. V. atypica appeared more susceptible to
-11 than the other bacteria tested but was more resistant to the RW library peptides 2C-3 and 2C-4.
|
|
|---|
For the binary and
-helix libraries, the results indicate that maximal S. mutans activity occurred in peptides with both high relative hydrophobicity and more than +3 net positive charge. Intermediate levels of activity were observed for peptides whose properties were dominated by either single trait. These results are consistent with what is known of most synthetic and natural AMPs with cationic amphipathic character and suggest that B-33,
-7, and the other active peptide sequences in these libraries may behave in a manner similar to that of other AMPs within this structural class; i.e., the positive charge of the peptide is thought to be required for the attraction of AMP to anionic bacterial membranes, while the amphipathicity is necessary for membrane interaction, helix transition, and cell killing (20, 38). These results also indicate that a high <Helix> value, on its own, may not correlate with increased anti-S. mutans activity for cationic amphipathic AMPs.
For the RW library, as was the case with the binary and
-helix libraries, the most-hydrophobic and -cationic sequences were the most active (2C-3 and -4). Despite the differences in length and periodicity compared with peptides in the other libraries, RW peptides may also be capable of gaining enhanced activity from improvements in initial peptide binding or membrane insertion. This idea is supported by evidence suggesting that Arg- and Trp-rich peptides, despite their low <Helix> values, form stable helix-like amphipathic arrangements upon membrane interaction which are stabilized by electrostatic bonds between the Trp
elections and the Arg functional group (20, 29). Thus, the unique sequence properties of the RW library peptides may allow them to obtain secondary structures that are highly conducive to antimicrobial activity.
Interestingly, our results indicate that fusion peptides, AMP dimers synthesized as single linear molecules, often have increased killing kinetics compared to their parental peptides. Some fusion peptides may function by increasing the number of helix-forming units per molecule at the membrane surface, as has been described for bundled AMPs (35). The data are unclear regarding the impact of linker regions between AMP segments, though it does appear that linker regions may affect individual peptides differently (see results for FRW-3 and FRW-9 in Tables 2 and 3). Studies are under way to directly investigate the impact of linker composition on AMP activity. Furthermore, our results suggest that the effect of constituent arrangement (which fusion peptide subunit goes at the C or N terminus) is also difficult to predict (compare the MICs of FB
-12 and FB
-20), though other work has demonstrated that amphipathic and putative helix-forming AMPs appear to be more tolerant of N-terminal additions for reasons that remain unclear (15, 39).
In conclusion, our results indicate that S. mutans appears to be susceptible to peptides with relatively high hydrophobicity and cationic charge, which were readily isolated from our constrained libraries. Additionally, fusion peptides constructed from conjoining active sequences from within and between these libraries improved the killing kinetics of these peptides.
Published ahead of print on 12 February 2007. ![]()
These authors contributed equally to this report. ![]()
|
|
|---|
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
Copyright © 2009 by the American Society for Microbiology. For an alternate route to Journals.ASM.org, visit: http://intl-journals.asm.org | More Info»